Wisconsin Criminal Defense Attorneys Named to 2025 Super Lawyers and Rising Stars
Birdsall Muller LLC is proud to share an announcement that reflects both the exceptional talent within our firm and the remarkable impact our attorneys continue to make across Wisconsin. We are honored to recognize our partner, Attorney John A. Birdsall, on his selection to the 2025 Wisconsin Super Lawyers list. An elite distinction reserved for only five percent of attorneys statewide. We are equally thrilled to celebrate our partner, Attorney Nicole A. Muller, on her repeat selection to the 2025 Wisconsin Rising Stars list, recognizing just 2.5 percent of attorneys in Wisconsin.
These honorable selections arrive during a period of extraordinary achievement for both Attorney Birdsall and Attorney Muller. Their work has garnered regional and national attention, including a recent feature on NBC’s Dateline.
In 2025 alone, they secured an acquittal in a 1992 double-homicide cold case, delivering long-overdue justice in a matter where their client remained in custody, fighting for his life for three years. In addition, Attorney Birdsall and Attorney Muller have collectively obtained over a dozen not guilty verdicts in just the last three months, reflecting their unwavering dedication, meticulous preparation, and unparalleled command of the courtroom.
These recognitions are far more than professional accolades—they are a testament to their consistent pursuit of justice, their steadfast commitment to protecting constitutional rights, and the level of excellence they bring to every client and every case.
We could not be more proud to have them leading our team.
These honorable selections arrive during a period of extraordinary achievement for both Attorney Birdsall and Attorney Muller. Their work has garnered regional and national attention, including a recent feature on NBC’s Dateline.
In 2025 alone, they secured an acquittal in a 1992 double-homicide cold case, delivering long-overdue justice in a matter where their client remained in custody, fighting for his life for three years. In addition, Attorney Birdsall and Attorney Muller have collectively obtained over a dozen not guilty verdicts in just the last three months, reflecting their unwavering dedication, meticulous preparation, and unparalleled command of the courtroom.
These recognitions are far more than professional accolades—they are a testament to their consistent pursuit of justice, their steadfast commitment to protecting constitutional rights, and the level of excellence they bring to every client and every case.
We could not be more proud to have them leading our team.
